Hot Tub Forum

Original => Hot Tub Forum => Topic started by: gaines on August 29, 2016, 02:37:35 am

Title: At what point is replacement a better option than repair?
Post by: gaines on August 29, 2016, 02:37:35 am
I've had an 8' Cal Spa for just over 10 years. It's been through a year of being mistreated by a renter before being moved to my new home, but has never had a leak. Now that we have the funds to repair it, I'm wondering if we might be better off just investing in a new unit.

Issues:

So what I'm wondering at this point is, should I be investing in refurbishing my current tub since the bones seem solid, or should we be considering purchasing a replacement?

BTW, we did build a custom deck around the hot tub so swapping them out will be a bit more of a pain, however the deck was designed with removable sections around the tub in addition to a trap door over the spa pack so anything under 94"x94" shouldn't be a problem.
Title: Re: At what point is replacement a better option than repair?
Post by: wmccall on August 29, 2016, 07:38:24 am
Welcome to the forum.  There was a lot of people here who have worked on spas more than I have, but the one key thing in your post was that I know the type of jets your Cal spa uses and once one starts failing it will be a cascading effect. Cost wise it may be less significant that other peices, but its time consuming annoyance. I think that might have been the point that pushed me to buying new.
Title: Re: At what point is replacement a better option than repair?
Post by: jmk1234 on August 30, 2016, 01:39:09 am
I hear you. I just bought a house with a reflections spa there with similar problems as yours and age too. Seller told me it would require a new motor(they still worked but sounded like can openers). I then discovered it was losing both pumps and the cover was garbage and dry rotted. I also noticed leaking coming from the plumbing but that came after my decision came to buy new but if I would have replaced all those parts just to discover that I am glad i decided to go new.  The point that put me over the top was not knowing whether the heater would need to be replaced and couldn't learn that until I replaced the pumps because that noise was just too loud and unbearable for the 15 minute duration of its automatic cycle.


Essentially I would have spent about 3000 to refurbish a tub that hadn't been run since at minimum fall of 2015.  Plus the combination of no warranty and expensive fees repair technicians charge just to show up. I decided to order a brand new Jacuzzi J-335. Now I will get reliability and warranty.